5 Major Money Mistakes I’ve Made (And How You Can Avoid Them)

February 4, 2020

Live mortgage free.

Fill out this form to learn how we paid off our mortgage in less than 5 years. And no, we didn't win the lottery. You'll also receive periodic updates from me to help you take your family to the next level.

Disclaimer: This post may contain affiliate links or links from our advertisers where we earn a commission, direct payment or products. Opinions are the author's alone, and this content has not been provided by, reviewed, approved or endorsed by any advertiser. Information shared on this site is for entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as professional advice.

Lately, I realized that I’ve been sharing a lot of really great things that are going on in my life (paying off our mortgage early, net worth wins and transitioning to my small business full-time). While that news fun to share and can be motivating for those of you reading my blog, I think it’s also important to share some of my money mistakes as well. 

That’s what the financial journey is all about. We’re not always hitting big wins all the time. There are a lot of mistakes, but those mistakes can sometimes be the biggest lessons and help us learn a lot.

And then there are mistakes that just really suck and you don’t learn anything from them!

Here are 5 major money mistakes I’ve made in my life. Hopefully, by sharing these money mistakes, it’ll help you avoid them in the future. 

1. Buying an Expensive Home I Couldn’t Afford

In 2004, I bought my first home. I was so proud to be a homeowner at 22 years old.

Bungalow
My First House!

Little did I know the true cost of homeownership. And man, did I learn quickly!

When I bought the home, I only put 10% down so I had some pretty high mortgage payments for a guy only making $38,000 per year. My mortgage payment was around $1,200.

When I decided that I wanted to switch careers at 23 years old, I took a pay cut of about $10,000. I did not think clearly about my mortgage payment when I made that decision.

This uneducated money decision left me with a mortgage payment around 50% of my monthly income. Add in the housing costs, that was about 70% of my income!

When all was said and done, I had about 30% of my tiny income to eat, watch Netflix (this was when they were sending the DVDs in the mail) and get a few beers with my friends. 

2. Leasing a Luxury Car When I’m in Debt

A few years and a few new career choices later, I landed myself at a new company making around $40,000. With my new-found wealth and a couple of extra roommates to help me pay my mortgage, I decided it would be smart to lease a luxury car. 

audi rings
I leased the four rings when I could only afford one!

I had no business leasing a luxury car because I was in student debt and in debt with my Home Equity Line of Credit (HELOC). And my income was not sufficient enough to afford it. 

Instead of leasing a luxury car I could have:

Nah … I decided that I needed a luxury car in my mid-20’s because it made me look cool. That decision, while fun, set me back as I headed toward some big moments in my life. 

3. Using My Student Loans to Buy My Wife’s Engagement Ring

Soon enough, I met the woman of my dreams. My wife Nicole!

Andy Hill and Nicole Hill
Andy and Nicole (circa 2009)

And I wanted her to be my wife right away, but I had NO money for the ring. 

Do you know why I had no money for the ring?

  • Bought a house I couldn’t afford
  • Decided to go back to school to get my MBA
  • Driving around in a luxury car

So did I decide to save up for the ring? Or buy a less expensive ring?

Nope! I decided to drop $5,000 and I used my student loans to pay for it.

Not only was I racking up tens of thousands of dollars in student loans for my MBA but I added on another $5,000 for Nicole’s ring. What a way to start the marriage!

4. Refinancing My Mortgage (and Then Moving Shortly After)

After we got married, the value of my home started to plummet during the Great Recession. In 2010, I owned a home valued at $140,000 but I owed $180,000 on it. Yikes… that's when I had a lovely negative net worth.

When 2012 rolled around, the value had risen enough to a point where I owed less on it than it was worth. Phew!

But the money mistake guy was back for more mistakes!

I decided it was smart to refinance my mortgage so I could lock in a rate at 5%. Now I had an adjustable-rate mortgage at the time and my rate had dropped down to 2.71% because the Libor Rate continued to go down. 

I didn’t understand any of this at the time. I just felt uneasy to have an Adjustable Rate Mortgage because it might adjust upward someday. So I refinanced. 

We ended up losing out on about $13,000 through lost interest payments and refinancing fees. This was a really dumb move. 

Also, to make matters worse, we decided to sell the home just a year later. It made NO sense for us to refinance our mortgage when we were planning to move. This was wasted money. 

5. Having Blind Faith in my Financial Advisor

Around this same time, I connected with an Investment Broker who was going to help us with our investments and retirement plan. At this point, we were both making some pretty good money and we needed someone to help us invest it. 

My blind faith in this individual was a big mistake. 

At one point, we had saved $100,000 and we asked him where we should put it if we were considering buying a home in the next couple of years. He suggested putting it in bond funds because they were a safe investment. 

What I didn’t understand was that there was a “front-load fee” that dropped our investment balance immediately. Additionally, the bond funds he put us in started to drop in value. 

Our $100,000 savings had dropped to around $95,000 in just a few months.

I should have known not to put any money in the stock market or bond market if I want it back in less than 5 years. I hoped my “advisor” would “advise” me against such things, but it feels like the front load was more important. 

Painful and pricey lesson learned. 

Oh, man … I feel like I just went through a financial therapy session! 

Even though these money mistakes are upsetting to relive and re-share, I learned so much from all of these experiences. And these lessons have truly shaped the way I approach money now. 

I like to keep things simple, have patience and realize that good things come with time and education. 


sad baby

Andy Hill

Andy Hill is the host of the Marriage, Kids and Money Podcast which focuses on helping young families build wealth. This 5-star rated podcast was nominated as "Best New Personal Finance Podcast" by Plutus. Andy's advice and personal finance experience have been featured in major media outlets like Business Insider, MarketWatch and NBC News.

4 Comments

  • Ah yes. Many of us have built a lot of wisdom from our mistakes! My husband and I came very close to building a house when we were double income no kids. We already had a house and we were never ever home! Luckily we got out of that one because we are still in our starter home living mortgage free.
    I also liked your engagement ring story. I recall in the 90s having to take a loan for my $1000. engagment ring!

    Reply
    • Sounds like you made a smart move with the build! I’d rather be mortgage-free in a starter home than neck-deep in my mortgage in a “dream home” any day!

      Reply
  • Andy, your podcast has become a go-to for me; your content is impressively consistent and helpful! I like your viewpoints and takes, and I think this article helps balance things out, as you said. I myself took a 401k loan for my wife’s ring. I’ve never regretted it (as I paid it back and have been a huge 401k investor since day one) but you made me consider it in the larger context here. I really liked seeing your progression of decision making as well; it makes me realize that good money decisions aren’t necessarily a switch to flip, but a movement over time towards smarter and smarter living.
    Thanks for providing such a family-centered take on money, FI, and love!

    Reply
    • This is such a thoughtful comment Matthew! Thank you so much. I truly appreciate how you say that progression and how small incremental wins over time make a huge difference.

      While, I’m upset at myself for using my student loans to buy my wife’s engagement ring … it’s the best investment I’ve ever made! We’re celebrating our 10 year anniversary in a few months!

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top